OSRS Redwood Birdhouse vs Magic Birdhouse: Which is Better?

In Old School RuneScape (OSRS), birdhouses are a popular method for training the Hunter skill while also providing players with a source of passive income through the collection of bird seeds and other rewards. Among the various types of birdhouses available, the Redwood and Magic birdhouses stand out due to their unique features and benefits. This article will compare these two birdhouse options to help players determine which one aligns best with their training goals and gameplay style.

The Redwood Birdhouse is a prominent option for players looking to enhance their Hunter experience in OSRS. This birdhouse requires level 50 Hunter to construct and can be built using 1 Redwood log, which can be obtained through woodcutting or purchased from the Grand Exchange. Once built, the Redwood Birdhouse can attract a variety of birds, including the common and rare types, which provide different rewards upon collection.

One of the key advantages of the Redwood Birdhouse is its significant experience yield. Players can gain 200 Hunter experience per birdhouse when they check it for birds, making it an efficient method for leveling up the skill. Additionally, the Redwood Birdhouse has a higher chance of attracting rare birds compared to the lower-tier birdhouses, which means players can potentially earn valuable rewards, such as bird nests containing seeds, rare items, or even the elusive pet birds.

Another noteworthy aspect of the Redwood Birdhouse is its low maintenance. Once constructed, it remains operational for a set period, allowing players to collect rewards without constant oversight. This feature makes it an ideal choice for players who engage in other activities while waiting for their birdhouses to yield results. Furthermore, the Redwood Birdhouse can hold up to 10 bird seeds at a time, increasing the potential rewards and experience gained with each collection.

In summary, the Redwood Birdhouse offers a balanced combination of experience gain, potential rewards, and ease of use. It serves as a solid option for players looking to advance their Hunter skill efficiently while also enjoying the benefits of passive income through the collection of bird-related rewards.

Overview of the Magic Birdhouse

Bird Houses Osrs Bruin Blog

The Magic Birdhouse is a popular feature in Old School RuneScape (OSRS) that allows players to engage in birdhouse trapping, a method of training their Hunter skill while also earning some passive income. This birdhouse offers a more advanced trapping experience compared to its predecessor, the regular Birdhouse, making it an appealing option for players looking to maximize their efficiency.

To use the Magic Birdhouse, players need to have completed the quest “A Fairy Tale II – Cure a Queen” and have a Hunter level of 68. Here’s a quick summary of its key features:

Location: The Magic Birdhouse can be found in different locations, including the Fossil Island and the Taverley area.
Trapping Method: Players can set up the birdhouse in a designated area, allowing birds to be trapped over time without the need for constant monitoring.
Experience Points: Players receive a significant amount of Hunter experience when collecting the trapped birds, making it a viable training method.
Profit Potential: The Magic Birdhouse offers a variety of bird types that can be trapped, each with their own value, leading to lucrative rewards.

Overall, the Magic Birdhouse combines convenience and profitability, making it an excellent choice for players looking to enhance their Hunter skill in OSRS.

Comparative Analysis: Experience Rates

When it comes to training Hunter in OSRS, experience rates are a critical factor for players to consider. Let’s take a closer look at how the Redwood Birdhouse and the Magic Birdhouse stack up against each other in terms of experience gains.

Birdhouse Type	Experience per Birdhouse	Time to Set Up	Overall Experience Rate
Redwood Birdhouse	150 XP	10 seconds	900-1,200 XP/hour
Magic Birdhouse	200 XP	15 seconds	1,200-1,500 XP/hour

As shown in the table, the Magic Birdhouse provides a higher experience gain per birdhouse compared to the Redwood Birdhouse. While the Redwood Birdhouse is faster to set up, the overall experience rates clearly favor the Magic option. This means that, in the long run, players will gain more experience by using the Magic Birdhouse.

In summary, if you’re focused on maximizing your experience rates, the Magic Birdhouse is the superior choice. Its higher XP yield combined with the potential for profitable bird trapping makes it a more effective training method than the Redwood Birdhouse.

5. Resource Requirements for Each Birdhouse

When it comes to setting up your birdhouses in Old School RuneScape (OSRS), understanding the resource requirements is crucial. Both the Redwood Birdhouse and the Magic Birdhouse have specific ingredients that you’ll need to gather before you can start building them. Let’s break it down:

Redwood Birdhouse Requirements

Logs: 1 Redwood log
Construction Level: 30
Birdhouse Frame: Requires crafting a birdhouse frame using the logs.
Location: Can be placed anywhere in the game where the player has access to trees.

Magic Birdhouse Requirements

Logs: 1 Magic log
Construction Level: 50
Birdhouse Frame: Similar to the Redwood, but requires higher-level logs.
Location: Accessible in various areas, particularly useful for high-level players.

In summary, if you’re just starting out and don’t have high levels in Woodcutting or Construction, the Redwood Birdhouse might be a better fit for your early game, while the Magic Birdhouse is tailored for players who have progressed further.

6. Profitability: Redwood vs Magic Birdhouses

Profitability is a key factor to consider when choosing between the Redwood and Magic Birdhouses in OSRS. Both options provide unique benefits, but they differ significantly in terms of the profits you can generate. Let’s explore the profitability of each:

Redwood Birdhouse Profitability

Experience per Hour: Around 20,000 XP
Birds Caught: Typically yields lower-tier birds.
Market Value: The items obtained from the Redwood birdhouses sell for moderate prices.
Time Investment: Requires less time to set up and maintain.

Magic Birdhouse Profitability

Experience per Hour: Around 30,000 XP
Birds Caught: Captures higher-tier birds, which are more valuable.
Market Value: The items received can sell for significantly higher prices.
Time Investment: Higher initial resource requirement, but greater returns over time.

In conclusion, while the Redwood Birdhouse is easier to access and requires fewer resources, the Magic Birdhouse offers better profitability potential for players willing to invest the time and effort. If you aim to maximize your profits, the Magic option is the way to go!

Best Practices for Using Birdhouses

When it comes to maximizing your experience with birdhouses in Old School RuneScape (OSRS), following some best practices can make all the difference. Whether you’re going for the Redwood or Magic birdhouse, here are some useful tips to enhance your birdhouse routine.

Plan Your Routes: Before you start using birdhouses, map out a route that allows you to efficiently check and refill them. This will save you time and make your experience smoother.
Utilize Birdhouse Teleports: If you’ve unlocked the “Birdhouse” teleport, use it to quickly access your birdhouses. This can significantly reduce your travel time, allowing for more efficient birdhouse management.
Check Timers: Know the respawn times of the birds. The Redwood birdhouse has a longer timer than the Magic birdhouse, so plan your visits accordingly. Generally, the Magic birdhouse takes around 50 minutes to respawn, while the Redwood takes about 70 minutes.
Prioritize Your Birdhouses: If you have both types, prioritize which ones to check based on your goals. If you’re after more experience and profit, the Magic birdhouse is the better option.
Use Your Resources Wisely: Make sure you have enough logs for building and maintaining your birdhouses. Stock up on both Redwood and Magic logs to ensure a continuous supply.

By adhering to these best practices, you’ll not only maximize your experience gains but also streamline your birdhouse activities, making it a more enjoyable and rewarding aspect of your OSRS journey.

Conclusion: Which Birdhouse Should You Choose?

Deciding between the Redwood and Magic birdhouses ultimately depends on your personal goals and playstyle in OSRS. Both birdhouses have their merits, but understanding their differences can guide you to make the best choice for your needs.

Feature	Redwood Birdhouse	Magic Birdhouse
Experience per Check	60 XP	120 XP
Respawn Time	70 minutes	50 minutes
Profit Potential	Moderate	High

In conclusion:

If you’re looking for a balance between experience and profit, the Redwood Birdhouse might be your best bet.
However, if you prioritize experience and higher profit margins, then the Magic Birdhouse is the way to go.

Ultimately, your choice will reflect your goals in the game. Choose wisely and enjoy your time with birdhouses in OSRS!