OSRS Crush Weapons Tier List Best Picks for PvM and PvP

In Old School RuneScape (OSRS), crush weapons are a vital part of any melee combatant’s arsenal, particularly when facing enemies with high defense or specific weaknesses to crush attacks, such as Cerberus, Tekton, or the Kalphite Queen. This comprehensive tier list ranks the best crush weapons based on their damage output, attack speed, special abilities, and overall utility in both Player vs. Monster (PvM) and Player vs. Player (PvP) scenarios. Whether you’re a free-to-play (F2P) player, an Ironman, or an endgame raider, this guide will help you choose the right crush weapon for your needs.

Crush weapons, including maces, mauls, warhammers, and some battleaxes, deliver powerful blunt damage, making them ideal against enemies like skeletons, trolls, and high-defense bosses. Their effectiveness depends on factors like crush attack bonus, strength bonus, attack speed, and special attacks. This tier list categorizes weapons into S, A, B, and C tiers, with S-tier being the most effective and C-tier being situational or entry-level options.

Why Crush Weapons Matter

Many OSRS monsters have specific weaknesses to crush attacks, making these weapons essential for efficient slayer tasks and boss fights. Additionally, crush weapons often come with unique special attacks that can lower enemy defense or deal burst damage, which is critical in both PvM and PvP.

S-Tier Crush Weapons

S-tier crush weapons are the cream of the crop, offering unmatched damage, speed, or utility. These are must-haves for high-level content and competitive play.

Inquisitor’s Mace

The Inquisitor’s Mace is the best one-handed crush weapon in OSRS, boasting a +95 crush attack bonus, +89 strength bonus, and an attack speed of 4 (2.4 seconds). Requiring 80 Attack, it’s a rare drop from The Nightmare and Phosani’s Nightmare. Its synergy with the Inquisitor’s armor set, which boosts crush damage and accuracy by up to 7.5%, makes it a top pick for PvM, especially against bosses like Cerberus or Tekton. In PvP, its speed and damage make it a deadly choice for combo setups.

Abyssal Bludgeon

The Abyssal Bludgeon is a two-handed powerhouse with a +102 crush attack bonus, +85 strength bonus, and an attack speed of 4. Crafted from three pieces dropped by the Abyssal Sire (requiring 85 Slayer), it needs 70 Attack and Strength to wield. Its special attack deals extra damage based on missing Prayer points, making it ideal for bosses like The Nightmare or Slayer tasks. Its high DPS makes it the best two-handed crush weapon for general PvM.

A-Tier Crush Weapons

A-tier weapons are highly effective but fall just short of S-tier due to slightly lower stats, higher requirements, or situational utility. They’re still excellent choices for most players.

Dragon Warhammer

The Dragon Warhammer is a one-handed weapon with a +95 crush attack bonus and +85 strength bonus, requiring 60 Strength. Its special attack, Smash, reduces the target’s Defense by 30% on hit, making it indispensable for high-defense bosses like Vorkath, General Graardor, and Tekton. Dropped by Lizardman Shamans (1/5000 drop rate), it’s a grind to obtain but a staple in endgame PvM. In PvP, it’s used to set up kills by lowering opponent defenses.

Elder Maul

The Elder Maul holds the highest crush attack bonus in OSRS at +135, paired with a +147 strength bonus. However, its slow attack speed of 6 (3.6 seconds) and two-handed nature limit its DPS, placing it in A-tier. Requiring 75 Attack and Strength, it’s a rare drop from the Chambers of Xeric. It shines in solo raids against high-defense targets but is less versatile than faster weapons like the Abyssal Bludgeon.

Zamorakian Hasta

The Zamorakian Hasta is a one-handed weapon with a +85 crush attack bonus, +75 strength bonus, and an attack speed of 4. Requiring 70 Attack, it’s crafted from a Zamorakian Spear (dropped by K’ril Tsutsaroth) via Otto Godblessed. Its fast attack speed and decent bonuses make it a great mid-to-high-level option for PvM, particularly against crush-weak bosses like Dagannoth Rex. Its defensive bonuses also make it viable for tanking roles.

B-Tier Crush Weapons

B-tier weapons are solid mid-level options or situational tools, often used by players progressing through the game or in specific scenarios.

Granite Maul

The Granite Maul is a two-handed weapon with a +81 crush attack bonus and +79 strength bonus, requiring 50 Attack and Strength. Dropped by Gargoyles (75 Slayer), its special attack, Quick Smash, delivers two rapid hits, making it a PvP favorite for burst damage in the Wilderness or Duel Arena. In PvM, it’s decent for mid-level content but outclassed by higher-tier options.

Viggora’s Chainmace

The Viggora’s Chainmace has a +67 crush attack bonus and +66 strength bonus, requiring 60 Attack. Its passive effect grants +50% damage and accuracy in the Wilderness, making it a top choice for Wilderness PvM, such as killing Revenants or Callisto. Charged with Revenant Ether, it’s less effective outside the Wilderness, limiting its versatility.

Verac’s Flail

The Verac’s Flail offers a +82 crush attack bonus and requires 70 Attack. When paired with the full Verac’s armor set, it has a 25% chance to ignore enemy Defense and Prayer, making it excellent for tanky bosses like Callisto. Its slower attack speed and reliance on the set effect place it in B-tier, but it’s a strong choice for Barrows runs or specific PvM encounters.

C-Tier Crush Weapons

C-tier weapons are entry-level or niche options, primarily used by F2P players, low-level accounts, or in very specific situations.

Hill Giant Club

The Hill Giant Club is the best-in-slot crush weapon for F2P players, with a +65 crush attack bonus and 40 Attack requirement. Dropped by Obor in Edgeville Dungeon, it’s comparable to a rune 2-handed sword but excels in crush damage. It’s a solid choice for F2P PvP and low-level PvM but quickly becomes obsolete in members’ worlds.

Sarachnis Cudgel

The Sarachnis Cudgel is a one-handed weapon with a +70 crush attack bonus and +65 strength bonus, requiring 65 Attack. Dropped by Sarachnis, it’s a decent mid-level option for Ironmen or players without access to better weapons. However, it’s outclassed by the Zamorakian Hasta and other A-tier options.

Crush Weapons Comparison Table

Weapon	Tier	Crush Bonus	Strength Bonus	Attack Speed	Requirements	Best Use
Inquisitor’s Mace	S	+95	+89	4 (2.4s)	80 Attack	PvM, PvP
Abyssal Bludgeon	S	+102	+85	4 (2.4s)	70 Attack, 70 Strength	PvM, Slayer
Dragon Warhammer	A	+95	+85	6 (3.6s)	60 Strength	PvM (Defense-lowering)
Elder Maul	A	+135	+147	6 (3.6s)	75 Attack, 75 Strength	PvM (High-defense targets)
Zamorakian Hasta	A	+85	+75	4 (2.4s)	70 Attack	PvM, Tanking
Granite Maul	B	+81	+79	5 (3.0s)	50 Attack, 50 Strength	PvP
Hill Giant Club	C	+65	+50	4 (2.4s)	40 Attack	F2P PvM, PvP

Choosing the Right Crush Weapon

Selecting a crush weapon depends on your combat level, playstyle, and goals. Here are some tips to guide your choice:

• F2P Players: Stick with the Hill Giant Club for its accessibility and solid stats in F2P worlds.
• Mid-Level Players: The Granite Maul or Sarachnis Cudgel are great stepping stones until you can access A-tier weapons like the Zamorakian Hasta.
• Endgame PvM: Prioritize the Inquisitor’s Mace or Abyssal Bludgeon for maximum DPS, with the Dragon Warhammer as a utility weapon for defense-lowering.
• PvP Enthusiasts: The Granite Maul and Inquisitor’s Mace excel in burst damage, while Viggora’s Chainmace dominates Wilderness encounters.
• Ironmen: Focus on grindable weapons like the Sarachnis Cudgel or Zamorakian Hasta before tackling high-level grinds for the Abyssal Bludgeon or Dragon Warhammer.

By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each crush weapon, you can optimize your combat setup for any challenge in OSRS. Whether you’re smashing through Slayer tasks or dominating in the Wilderness, this tier list ensures you’re equipped with the best tools for the job.